EarthLink vs AT&T Internet Plans & Fees 2022

earthlink vs at&t graphic

HighSpeedOptions prides itself on providing honest, quality content. While we may be compensated when you make a purchase through links on our site, all opinions are our own. Here's how we make money.

Interested in swapping internet providers, but don’t know whether to go with EarthLink or AT&T? Both offer a variety of internet plans and enough data usage for any lifestyle. However, there are a few key differences between them, like speeds and internet fees, that can make or break your decision. Follow along to discover which provider best suits your needs.

Overview

ProviderInternet TypeDownload Speeds Up To*ContractsExtra Fees
EarthLinkDSL & Fiber1000 MbpsNoneEquipment rental, ETF, Installation fee
AT&TDSL & Fiber1000 Mbps1-year & 2-yearEquipment rental, ETF, Installation fee, data overages
ProviderEarthLink
Internet TypeDSL & Fiber
Download Speeds Up To*1000 Mbps
ContractsNone
Extra FeesEquipment rental, ETF, Installation fee
ProviderAT&T
Internet TypeDSL & Fiber
Download Speeds Up To*1000 Mbps
Contracts1-year & 2-year
Extra FeesEquipment rental, ETF, Installation fee, data overages

Comparing Internet Fees

When it comes to internet fees and plan features, no two internet providers are the same. Check out the top internet features of EarthLink and AT&T below to see what may be included in your initial, ongoing, and final billing statements.

graphic of internet fee icons

Data Limits

EarthLink does not impose any hard data limits or slowdowns on its service whereas AT&T does place data limits on select internet plans. On its DSL plans, AT&T offers a 1 TB data allowance per month, and for most users, this is plenty of data to work with.

If a customer exceeds this limit, blocks of 50 GB will automatically be added to your bill for an extra fee of $10 each plus tax. Added charges will never exceed $100 per month, no matter how much data you use. Unlimited data can be purchased separately for an additional $30 per month or be automatically applied if you maintain a bundle of TV and internet on a combined bill.

Contracts & Termination Fees

EarthLink internet plans require a 12-month contract and an early termination fee (ETF) of up to $200. When your 12-month contract is up, you can lock in the same rate for another 12 months or opt to pay month-to-month: whatever works best for you. No credit checks are required.

In comparison, AT&T internet plans do not require annual contracts, but it does give customers the option to lock in pricing with either a one or two-year contract. If you end your service before your agreement expires, you may have to pay an ETF of up to $180 for 1-year contract or $360 for a 2-year contract ($15 for every month left on your contract).

Installation Fees

Both providers offer professional installations. EarthLink charges a one-time fee of $79.95 while AT&T charges a one-time fee of $99.99. AT&T is a little more expensive, but they earn back brownie points for offering online ordering.

Equipment Rentals

When it comes to renting your internet modem or router, AT&T and EarthLink are pretty evenly matched. AT&T charges a monthly equipment fee of $10, and EarthLink charges $9.95. If you prefer to save money by using your own equipment, both AT&T and EarthLink have no problem with it.

Below we list a handful of EarthLink HyperLinkTM Internet plans. Speeds and pricing will vary by your physical location, but this will give you an idea of what speeds are available if you live in an area where EarthLink internet is available.

EarthLink Internet PlansDownload Speed Up To*Upload Speed Up To*Starting Price*
HyperLink 30Mb30 Mbps1.5 Mbps$59.95/mo.
HyperLink 50Mb50 Mbps50 Mbps$49.95/mo.
HyperLink 80Mb80 Mbps40 Mbps$69.95/mo.
HyperLink 140Mb140 Mbps100 Mbps$79.95/mo.
HyperLink 500Mb500 Mbps200 Mbps$89.95/mo.
HyperLink 1 Gbps1000 Mbps1000 Mbps$99.95/mo.
*Speeds, prices, and plans vary by location and distance, do not include additional fees, and are subject to change at any time. 12/6/21
EarthLink Internet PlansHyperLink 30Mb
Download Speed Up To*30 Mbps
Upload Speed Up To*1.5 Mbps
Starting Price*$59.95/mo.
EarthLink Internet PlansHyperLink 50Mb
Download Speed Up To*50 Mbps
Upload Speed Up To*50 Mbps
Starting Price*$49.95/mo.
EarthLink Internet PlansHyperLink 80Mb
Download Speed Up To*80 Mbps
Upload Speed Up To*40 Mbps
Starting Price*$69.95/mo.
EarthLink Internet PlansHyperLink 140Mb
Download Speed Up To*140 Mbps
Upload Speed Up To*100 Mbps
Starting Price*$79.95/mo.
EarthLink Internet PlansHyperLink 500Mb
Download Speed Up To*500 Mbps
Upload Speed Up To*200 Mbps
Starting Price*$89.95/mo.
EarthLink Internet PlansHyperLink 1 Gbps
Download Speed Up To*1000 Mbps
Upload Speed Up To*1000 Mbps
Starting Price*$99.95/mo.
*Speeds, prices, and plans vary by location and distance, do not include additional fees, and are subject to change at any time. 12/6/21

AT&T Internet Plans

Below we list a range of AT&T internet plans to give you an idea of what it offers. Note that speeds, pricing, and availability all depend on your physical location.

AT&T Internet PlanDownload Speed Up To*Upload Speed Up To*Starting Price*
Internet 2525 Mbps5 Mbps$45/mo.
Internet 5050 Mbps10 Mbps$45/mo.
Internet 100100 Mbps100 Mbps$35/mo.
Internet 300300 Mbps300 Mbps$35/mo.
Internet 500500 Mbps500 Mbps$45/mo.
Internet 10001000 Mbps1000 Mbps$60/mo.
*Speeds, prices, and plans vary by location, do not include additional fees, and are subject to change at any time. Prices above include an AutoPay discount of $5 per month. 12/6/21
AT&T Internet PlanInternet 25
Download Speed Up To*25 Mbps
Upload Speed Up To*5 Mbps
Starting Price*$45/mo.
AT&T Internet PlanInternet 50
Download Speed Up To*50 Mbps
Upload Speed Up To*10 Mbps
Starting Price*$45/mo.
AT&T Internet PlanInternet 100
Download Speed Up To*100 Mbps
Upload Speed Up To*100 Mbps
Starting Price*$35/mo.
AT&T Internet PlanInternet 300
Download Speed Up To*300 Mbps
Upload Speed Up To*300 Mbps
Starting Price*$35/mo.
AT&T Internet PlanInternet 500
Download Speed Up To*500 Mbps
Upload Speed Up To*500 Mbps
Starting Price*$45/mo.
AT&T Internet PlanInternet 1000
Download Speed Up To*1000 Mbps
Upload Speed Up To*1000 Mbps
Starting Price*$60/mo.
*Speeds, prices, and plans vary by location, do not include additional fees, and are subject to change at any time. Prices above include an AutoPay discount of $5 per month. 12/6/21

Availability

Your choice as a customer really comes down to where you live. Internet service providers have networks spread across the US, and no two ISPs offer the same coverage. Check out AT&T and EarthLink’s availability below to learn more. 

AT&T

Currently, AT&T offers service in over 20 states, making it one of the largest providers in the United States. If you live in Indiana or New Jersey where their coverage is greatest, you’re likely to find and enjoy the most options. In addition, customers also get access to more than 30,000 free WiFi hotspots.

EarthLink serves over 35 states, making it one of the largest DSL providers in the US. It doesn’t offer any free WiFi hotspots, but it does have decent coverage in states like California, New Mexico, and Texas.

We recommend entering your zip code below to know for sure what’s available near you.

Recap

AT&T offers more affordable internet plans. However, EarthLink offers slightly better options related to internet fees. Based on their offerings, check out which lifestyles each provider pairs best with.

Budget Shopper

If you’re shopping on a budget, AT&T offers some of the cheapest internet plans we’ve seen. AT&T plans are anywhere from $5 to $40 cheaper than EarthLink plans depending on which one you choose, and it offers 1-year and 2-year price locks.

Heavy User

Both internet service providers offer similar download speeds, yet AT&T offers faster upload speeds on its top fiber plans. If you require fast speeds to upload large files for things like remote work and content creation, we recommend choosing a plan with generous upload speeds.

Single-Person Household

While AT&T offers faster speeds on select plans, not all users need that much bandwidth. If you live in a single-person household or only occasionally use the internet for things like checking emails or browsing the web, EarthLink may be a better fit for you. Its 50 Mbps for under $50 is the perfect plan for someone with this type of lifestyle.

To shop internet providers near you, enter your zip code below.

Enter your zip code to see providers near you

search
Paula Novo
Written By
Paula Novo
Written By
Paula Novo
With over four years of telecom experience, Paula Novo is the Site Editor for HighSpeedOptions. She has helped develop the criteria by which HighSpeedOptions reviews and recommends internet service providers. Paula also leads HighSpeedOptions' coverage of the digital divide, broadband policy, and ISP reviews.