HighSpeedOptions prides itself on providing honest, quality content. While we may be compensated when you make a purchase through links on our site, all opinions are our own. Here’s how we make money.

If you’re in an area where you can choose between EarthLink internet and AT&T internet , we’ve got lots of information about each provider to help make your decision easier. While both offer reliable fiber internet, they also have a few differences like data caps and annual contracts. Read on for the full breakdown of prices, plans, and features each offers.

logo
  • Best internet protection
  • Unlimited data included
  • No credit checks
logo
  • Variety of plans
  • Wide availability
  • Fiber internet speeds

Internet Plans

Our Picks

logologo

Staring Price

$49.95/mo. – $59.95/mo.$55/mo. – $80/mo.

Max Download

5 Gbps – 100 Mbps300 Mbps – 940 Mbps

Data Caps

NoNo

Equipment Fee

$12.95/mo.$10/mo.

Check AvailabilityCheck Availability

Our Picks

logo

Staring Price

$49.95/mo. – $59.95/mo.

Max Download

5 Gbps – 100 Mbps

Data Caps

No

Equipment Fee

$12.95/mo.
Check Availability

Our Picks

logo

Staring Price

$55/mo. – $80/mo.

Max Download

300 Mbps – 940 Mbps

Data Caps

No

Equipment Fee

$10/mo.
Check Availability

Pricing, speeds, offers, and availability vary by service address and are subject to change at any time. Additional fees, taxes, and terms may apply. As of 7/18/22.

While EarthLink internet plans are available in 50 states, its service areas are somewhat limited. If you do live where EarthLink is available, there are many features to look forward to, like unlimited data, symmetrical speeds, and a fixed-price guarantee. Earthlink offers speeds up to 5 Gbps over fiber internet in select areas, making it ideal for households with multiple, simultaneous users.

AT&T Internet Plans

While only available in 21 states, AT&T has a bigger footprint in larger cities than EarthLink. AT&T internet plans deliver for the most demanding users. With speeds up to 940 Mbps over fiber internet, you’ll get reliability from a connection type that has a lot of growth potential. AT&T offers up-front pricing with no annual contracts, active internet security, and state-of-the-art equipment.

logo

Internet Features

EarthLink and AT&T each offer high-quality internet services with high speeds, reliability, and security. Have a look at our side-by-side comparison of the two providers.

logo
logo

Data Caps

There are no data caps with EarthLink, so you can do all the things you love to do online without worrying about getting charged more.

Data Caps

AT&T imposes internet data caps, but only on its lower-speed plans. Plans with speeds greater than 100 Mbps do not have data caps.

Fast Speeds

While EarthLink offers 5 Gbps fiber internet, it is only available in select areas. Its 100 Mbps and 1 Gbps plans are more widely available.

Fast Speeds

AT&T delivers its internet service over an evolving fiber network with speeds up to 940 Mbps. As its network develops, the potential for faster speeds increases.

Contracts

EarthLink requires customers to agree to a 12-month contract in order to receive internet services.

Contracts

While AT&T internet service doesn’t require a contract, there may be an early termination fee applied when you cancel.

Security

Virus and spam protection are included for free with Earthlink services, as well as an app to administer and monitor your service.

Security

AT&T offers ActiveArmor™ with its internet service, which protects your devices from cyber threats, even when you’re on WiFi.

SHOW MORE
logo

Data Caps

There are no data caps with EarthLink, so you can do all the things you love to do online without worrying about getting charged more.

Fast Speeds

While EarthLink offers 5 Gbps fiber internet, it is only available in select areas. Its 100 Mbps and 1 Gbps plans are more widely available.

Contracts

EarthLink requires customers to agree to a 12-month contract in order to receive internet services.

Security

Virus and spam protection are included for free with Earthlink services, as well as an app to administer and monitor your service.

SHOW MORE
logo

Data Caps

AT&T imposes internet data caps, but only on its lower-speed plans. Plans with speeds greater than 100 Mbps do not have data caps.

Fast Speeds

AT&T delivers its internet service over an evolving fiber network with speeds up to 940 Mbps. As its network develops, the potential for faster speeds increases.

Contracts

While AT&T internet service doesn’t require a contract, there may be an early termination fee applied when you cancel.

Security

AT&T offers ActiveArmor™ with its internet service, which protects your devices from cyber threats, even when you’re on WiFi.

SHOW MORE

Internet Fees

It is important to know that the prices providers advertise with their plans do not include taxes and other internet fees. Have a look at this list of fees from each provider that may increase your monthly bill.

logo
logo

Installation

EarthLink requires a professional installation for all internet services, which starts at $79.95.

Installation

While the cost of a professional installation is about $100, AT&T does offer an option for free self-installation.

Overage Fees

Since EarthLink internet services have unlimited data, there are no overage fees to worry about.

Overage Fees

For the plans that have data caps, AT&T charges $10 for each 50 GB over the monthly allotment. You may also upgrade to unlimited data for $30/mo. for plans starting at 100 Mbps.

Equipment Fees

EarthLink charges $12.95/mo. for equipment rental, but you can use your own equipment with most EarthLink internet plans.

Equipment Fees

AT&T offers a WiFi gateway rental for $10/mo. It is required for all AT&T internet plans.

Price Increases

While it does require a 12-month contract, EarthLink won’t hike up your monthly price after that contract ends.

Price Increases

AT&T monthly prices are not tied to any promotions. However, AT&T reserves the right to increase prices and certainly has over time.

Early Termination

If you decide to cancel your internet service, EarthLink may charge up to $200 for early termination.

Early Termination

AT&T will charge up to $480 (pro-rated monthly) if you decide to cancel your service early.

SHOW MORE
logo

Installation

EarthLink requires a professional installation for all internet services, which starts at $79.95.

Overage Fees

Since EarthLink internet services have unlimited data, there are no overage fees to worry about.

Equipment Fees

EarthLink charges $12.95/mo. for equipment rental, but you can use your own equipment with most EarthLink internet plans.

Price Increases

While it does require a 12-month contract, EarthLink won’t hike up your monthly price after that contract ends.

Early Termination

If you decide to cancel your internet service, EarthLink may charge up to $200 for early termination.

SHOW MORE
logo

Installation

While the cost of a professional installation is about $100, AT&T does offer an option for free self-installation.

Overage Fees

For the plans that have data caps, AT&T charges $10 for each 50 GB over the monthly allotment. You may also upgrade to unlimited data for $30/mo. for plans starting at 100 Mbps.

Equipment Fees

AT&T offers a WiFi gateway rental for $10/mo. It is required for all AT&T internet plans.

Price Increases

AT&T monthly prices are not tied to any promotions. However, AT&T reserves the right to increase prices and certainly has over time.

Early Termination

AT&T will charge up to $480 (pro-rated monthly) if you decide to cancel your service early.

SHOW MORE

Picking a Provider

EarthLink and AT&T are both excellent internet options. EarthLink may be available in more states and offer faster top speeds, but AT&T has more availability within the states it operates and is somewhat less per Mbps than Earthlink.

Earthlink: Best for Speed & Availability

With a top speed of 5 Gbps and services available in 50 states, EarthLink internet has the edge here. However, keep in mind that that top speed is in select areas and EarthLink is not available state-wide in all 50 states.

AT&T: Best for Budget Shoppers

Although AT&T internet may offer services in fewer states than EarthLink, it has better coverage within those states. Its top speed is 1 Gbps, but AT&T’s prices are considerably lower per Mbps than EarthLink’s prices.

Enter your zip code to see providers near you.

search
Keith Carlson
Written By
Keith Carlson
Written By
Keith Carlson
Keith is a Contributing Writer for HighSpeedOptions with over 10 years of experience in writing and marketing. He has written for and contributed to organizations in the non-profit, financial, and enterprise internet and cable service industries. At HighSpeedOptions, Keith covers everything from broadband news to emerging technologies and how they complement different lifestyles and budgetary needs. In his free time, Keith enjoys spending time with his family, reading as many books as he can, and photography.